Makeup Review: L’Oreal Pencil Perfect Eyeliner

Greetings! Today marks the first day of my Friday Review series. Every Friday, I will review makeup and skin care products. Since eyeliner is an important part of your overall look, I’m reviewing L’Oreal Pencil Perfect Eyeliner today.

You’ll remember that I used this eyeliner in a previous post: Tutorial Tuesday: Sunrise Eyes. As you can see, this eyeliner goes on very smoothly. That’s the best part about it. It’s a creamy eyeliner that, as it says on the product itself, is a self-advancing liner. This means that you never have to sharpen it.

Sunrise Eyes - Eyeliner CompletePros: The ease of use is amazing. It goes on smoothly because it’s creamier than a regular pencil liner. It’s also easier to use than liquid eyeliner, which can sometimes be difficult to manage. The colors are great and deep. The price is also amazing at usually only $3.99 per stick.

Cons: The plastic cap is flimsy. Mine cracked after only a week or so. Because of that, I have to be careful putting it on because if I press too hard, it will smash the tip of the liner.

The low price of this eyeliner is a big draw for me. Not to mention the fact that it is just so easy to use. I’ve only used their Carbon Black variety, but I imagine that the other colors of the L’Oreal Pencil Perfect Eyeliner are just as good. It’s also easy to find at drug stores and online. Still, with the flimsy case, this product doesn’t get a perfect score.


You can pick up this eyeliner in drug stores or big box stores, or online at or Amazon.


Tagged as: , ,

Leave a Response